If you’re looking for a reliable Restaurants in Hertel Ave, 1292 Hertel Ave, Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery is a top choice. Our customers have given us 4.50 stars across 466 reviews, and we’re proud to offer accessible facilities along with a great selection of frozen treats.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
A delicious coffee-flavored Italian dessert. Ladyfingers dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar and mascarpone cheese, flavored with cocoa.
Your choice of carrot cake, chocolate cake, chocolate peanut butter cake, chocolate raspberry cake, or cassata cake.
Your choice of carrot cake, chocolate cake, chocolate peanut butter cake, chocolate raspberry cake, limoncello cake or cassata cake.
Made with ricotta and Nutella, yum yum unbelievable.
Goat cheese and marinated mushrooms on a bed of greens topped with truffle oil vinaigrette with croutons.
Marinated eggplant, fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, mixed greens, basil and oil and vinegar dressing on top of bread.
Mixed greens, feta cheese, chi-chi beans, grape tomatoes and apples and tossed with balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
Fresh spinach, Gorgonzola, mushrooms, avocado and olives, topped with crisp pancetta (Italian bacon) and tossed with raspberry vinaigrette.
Mixed greens, artichokes, cucumber, sesame and sunflower seeds and shaved asiago cheese and tossed with sesame vinaigrette dressing.
Mixed greens, croutons, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing with anchovies served on the side.
Mandarin oranges, walnuts and raisins, tossed with mixed greens and walnut dressing.
Traditional pasta al dente topped with Romeo and Juliet's fresh, delicious homemade tomato sauce. Served with Romeo and Juliet's own hand-rolled meatballs.
Favorite. Pounded fresh chicken cutlets breaded and baked with Romeo and Juliet's fresh, delicious homemade tomato sauce and topped with mozzarella. Served with a side of pasta al dente.
Italian risotto cooked al dente with fresh ground mild Italian sausage mixed with mushrooms, stuffed inside a large sweet red pepper topped with Romeo and Juliet's fresh, delicious homemade tomato sauce and baked to perfection. Served with a side of sautéed fresh green beans.
Tube like pasta stuffed with fresh ricotta cheese baby fresh spinach topped with melt mozzarella served with our meatless marinara sauce.
Choice of marinara sauce, Gorgonzola walnuts cream sauce, pesto or red pepper, peas and basil on a blush cream sauce.
Layers of ground beef sautéed with red wine, Italian ricotta and lasagne, topped with mozzarella and baked al dente. Served with a side of sautéed fresh green beans.
A blend of ground beef, baked prosciutto, parmigiano, and regional herbs, stuffed with a hard boiled egg and served with a choice a pasta or green beans.
A potato based gnocchi filled with asiago cheese with your choice a sauce sprinkled with romano cheese
Fresh eggplant sliced thin, dipped with fresh bread crumbs and baked with mozzarella cheese and Romeo and Juliet's fresh, delicious homemade tomato sauce. Served with a side of pasta al dente.
A potato based gnocchi topped with your choice of sauce and sprinkled with Romano
An egg based pasta in homemade bolognese sauce tapped with parmesan
Spinach stuffed Ravioli with your choice of sauce and Romani cheese
Ravioli stuffed with Butternut Squash topped with your choice of sauce and sprinkled with Romano cheese
Choice of marinara sauce, gorgonzola walnuts cream sauce, pesto or red pepper, peas, and basil on a blush cream sauce.
Lobster stuffed ravioli topped with you choice of sauce sprinkled with romano
Capicola, mozzarella, tomato and roasted portobello mushrooms.
Roast beef with tomato and provolone cheese.
Seasoned Italian ham and fresh mozzarella covered with fresh tomato sauce.
Thinly sliced turkey breast with provolone cheese and tomato.
An artwork of prosciutto crudo, soppressata, capicola, salami and mozzarella cheese.
Fresh mozzarella, fresh tomato, oil and basil on ciabatta bread.
A romance of spinach, eggplant, tomato and provolone cheese.
Sliced chicken breast, fresh spinach, cherry hot pepper and melted provolone.
Tuna fish, Romano cheese, mayo and tomato on healthy multigrain bread.
Favorite. Marinated artichokes, roasted red peppers and portobello mushrooms with provolone cheese on olive focaccia.
Combination of garlic, fresh tomatoes, diced scallions, shredded mozzarella and Romano.
Romeo and Juliet's famous pizza dough rolled with spinach, provolone, Romano, and shredded mozzarella then baked together.
Favorite. A delicious combination of shredded mozzarella, Romano, Gorgonzola and Cheddar cheese.
Favorite. Shredded mozzarella, fresh tomato sauce and basil baked over their own pizza crust.
Roasted portobello covered with shredded mozzarella, Gorgonzola, garlic and basil.
A wonderful combination of eggplant, portobello mushrooms, fresh tomato, Kalamata olives, shredded mozzarella and Romano. How refreshing!.
Favorite. Winner of the Ultimate Pizza Showdown 2010 from Buffalo Spree.
Marinated artichokes, Kalamata olives, soppressata (Italian salami), shredded mozzarella and Romano cheese and tomato sauce.
Homemade 100% meatless zuppa.
Italian hot peppers stuffed with cheese, red peppers, spinach and breadcrumbs, then baked to perfection and accompanied with crostini.
Baked brie topped with toasted almond stuffed with fresh strawberry, accompanied with fresh fruit and crostini.
Albacore tuna, capers, sun-dried tomato and lemon and olive oil, topped with toasted almonds on a crostini.
Delicious homemade Italian wedding 100% beef meatball, kale.
Risotto ball with sausage, mozzarella, carrots, peas and porcini mushrooms, breaded and baked to perfection.
Seasoned tomato and mozzarella cheese baked on focaccia.
Marinated sweet pepper, eggplant, onions, sun-dried tomatoes, basil and shaved asiago on homemade ciabatta.
Fresh mozzarella cheese with tomato slices, slightly seasoned with extra olive oil and accompanied with crostini.
Marinated artichokes and peppadew stuffed with goat cheese and cream cheese, eggplant, soppressata, prosciutto crudo and assorted cheeses, accompanied with roasted garlic and crostini.
Juliet's peppers piccanti baked with homemade tomato sauce and then topped with mozzarella.
Coke-Cola, Diet Coke, Sprite, lemonade.
Lemon or orange.
Hear from our valued guests
Fantastic food, service, and atmosphere. Pizza is always rich and delicious, and their desserts are authentic and legit. Any night I can eat at Romeo and Juliet's is a good night.
What a delightful place. So cute and soooo cozy. Great outside patio seating, fresh coffee, an amazing bakery full of desserts, and a friendly and fast staff. Had the triple chocolate cake and a steamed froth espresso. We had a great time and 100% will visit again! Check it out!
Devoured this pizza with my partner. Enjoyed the sparkling water drinks and a napoleon as well. Shared a delicious and romantic patio dinner for under $30. Excited to return for more Italian treats!
I was wanted to chime in here about their doordash! And I have to say I’m just so impressed the pasta I ordered was wrapped with care and the slice of cake I ordered was done the same! I’ve never had any food or drink from this restaurant before and the pasta is absolutely delicious! They gave me a side of bread that was so freshly made that I couldn’t be happier with! 10/10 I will be visiting the locations! Because if it’s as good as the take out I’m a lifelong fan now
Stopped in while doing laundry and was hankering for something sweet and opted for the Peanut butter chocolate cake ($6), per the staffers recommendation. It was in a cooler so I let it warm up a bit and it was really good. well made, and generously sliced.
Was very good but the paninis were amazing with a wide selection. The atmosphere and location is very ideal whether dining inside or on the patio. Also make sure you don’t leave without having a cannoli! I will definitely be back.
We stopped by to grab some dessert. Everything looked so good that we decided to get a few different ones to try. The chocolate peanut butter cake is one of the best I've had. The lemoncello is light with an excellent flavor. The napoleon was perfect. I cant wait to go back and try some others
We went here to have brunch. Everything was good with the food and service. We did decide to sit outside during a heatwave so I do not recommend that. The food tasted very fresh. The portions were very big. I really liked the bread and garlicky paste. Very soft and the garlic was so tasty. The service was good. Nothing negative to say here. She was friendly. The atmosphere is nice. Sitting outside, you have a nice view of the busy street or you can dine inside where it's much quieter and darkly lit. Overall, good experience. This would be a place I would consider revisiting if I'm feeling italian.
What more can be said of a local staple that hasn't already been said? I feel like anything I say will have been said already, in another voice, at another time. Well here goes: Food: If you had any doubts before, set them aside. Portions are huge, sauce is flavorful. Whether you opt for a pizza with crisp, thin slices, a panino with options galore, or one of many pasta choices. I've had so many in the several times I've visited, and they do not disappoint. I WILL eat the burratta and suffer the consequences of my actions because it's just that kind of place. Service: Olive Garden doesn't have shit on this place, I feel like family here more than I do in that half baked monstrosity of a restaurant. I don't need breadsticks when I have fresh bread and tapenade brought to my table. Bread is the name of the game, and the servers are playing pro. Everyone has shitty days, but the people here make that a little better. Atmosphere: Okay, it's a little kitschy. But if that doesn't perfectly encapsulates the Italian-American experience, I'm not sure what does. I know I'm in the right place when I come through the doors and I see cannoli, pannetone, and tiramisu in front of me. If an Italian restaurant doesn't have the little statue of the chef guy there, I DO NOT WANT IT. Give it a go, and make sure you save room for dessert.
We LOVED this spot. Smaller but big on charm & taste. Authentic Italian food that smells & tastes fantastic. Perfectly cooked. Friendly staff, not overcrowded, & food came out fast. They have one half that is a sit down restaurant with service staff & the other half is the bakery & take out/ window service & a self serve seating area that's less formal if you just want a quick slice of pizza or pie. It was really decked out for Christmas, very beautiful & fun. Fyi: Street parking only. Will return!!
Common questions about Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery is located at 1292 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216, United States , Hertel Ave, 1292 Hertel Ave, United States.
You can reach Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery by calling +1 716-873-5730.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery has a rating of 4.5 out of 5 based on 466 customer reviews.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following service options: Delivery, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following offerings: Coffee.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following amenities: Restroom.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following planning: Quick visit.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Romeo & Juliet’s Caffè & Bakery features the following parking: Free street parking, Paid street parking.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
